In a discussion with one of my friends at work, we were debating how the opposing team has an effect on who the people come to watch and how many come to watch the team play that opponent. Without taking, in account the day of the week, because a Thursday get away game will draw less than a Friday night game pretty well all the time, I compiled the teams that the Cardinals played in the Central, East and West of the National league and the few American League teams that they played in those few years. I also found out the total numbers of attendance and average number per game, as well as the highest attended game and the lowest. Let's look at the yearly breakdowns first
2010: 86 W, 76 L
- Total Attendance: 3,300,588
- Empty Seats: 261,387
- Average: 92.66% Capacity or 40747
- Largest Attendance: 4/12/10, Houston Astros, Opening Day, 46,918, 106.69%
- Lowest Attendance: 4/27/10, Atlanta Braves, 35,257, 80.18%
2011: 90 W, 72 L
- Total Attendance: 3,093,954
- Empty Seats: 468,021
- Average: 86.86% Capacity or 38197
- Largest Attendance: 3/31/11, San Diego Padres, Opening Day, 46,368, 105.44%
- Lowest Attendance: 4/5/11, Pittsburgh Pirates, 32,007, 72.78%
2012: 88 W, 74 L
- Total Attendance: 3,262,109
- Empty Seats: 299,866
- Average: 91.58% Capacity or 40,272
- Largest Attendance: 4/13/12, Chicago Cubs, Opening Day, 46,882, 106.61%
- Lowest Attendance: 9/5/12, New York Mets, 30,090, 68.43%
Now lets take a closer look at each individual team that brings the fans in to the games to watch or root against the Cardinals. First we will start with the NL Central.
National League Central
- Chicago Cubs, 43,293, 98.45%
- Milwaukee Brewers, 40,956, 93.13%
- Cincinnati Reds, 39,887, 90.70%
- Pittsburgh Pirates, 38,882, 88.41%
- Houston Astros, 37,022, 84.19%
There are no real surprises here, the Cubs, the Cardinals bitter and long time rival, lead that way as it should with 98.45% attendance rate. The Brewers came in second thanks mostly to their 2011 campaign with Prince Fielder and Ryan Braun. The Reds came in third and outside of Brandon Phillips and Johnny Cueto it doesn't seem to peak the fans interest like the others. The Bucos are about where you would think them to be with teams that don't seem to have the star power to bring in the fans. Then there is the lowly Astros, it may be a good thing that they are no longer in the NL Central, because now the Cardinals can bring in a team that fans will want to go see and fill the stands (I know that MLB sets the schedule).
National League East
- Atlanta Braves, 40,242, 91.51%
- Philadelphia Phillies, 39,139, 89.00%
- Florida/Miami Marlins, 38,670, 87.94%
- New York Mets, 38,151, 86.76%
- Washington Nationals, 37,250, 84.71%
The NL East doesn't surprise me much outside of the Marlins. The Braves have been one of the best NL teams, outside of the Cardinals, in the last 20 years. The Braves also bring some history to Busch Stadium. The Phillies have many well know stars and names that people would like to come see play, but after their start this year it is clear to see that their window maybe closing in the city of Brotherly Love. The Marlins, oh the Woeful Marlins, they get a new stadium, sign a bunch of players and then the owners takes a dump on all his fans...but they seem to bring more interest than the Mets which is interesting. The Mets were the Cardinal's bitter rival in the 1980's but since the Mets have fallen into the doldrums after Adam Wainwright buckled the knees of current Cardinal Carlos Beltran they just haven't been the same team, well save for David Wright. The Nationals still probably have that moniker as that team that is fairly terrible but with up and coming stars like Stephen Strasburg and Bryce Harper they might start to become a fairly big draw in STL in the future.
National League West
- San Diego Padres, 39,617, 90.09%
- San Francisco Giants, 39,393, 89.58%
- Colorado Rockies, 39,036, 88.77%
- Los Angeles Dodgers, 38,833, 88.31%
- Arizona Diamondbacks, 37,228, 84.66%
The NL West is a big surprise to me, just for the fact that the Dodgers are fourth. What this tells me is that folks from the Midwest don't care as much about the Dodgers as the rest of the country would like us to, I'm talking to you ESPiN. The Padres come in first in this group and they are here because of two weekend series which draw more crowd, but they beat out the World Champions from 2010 and 2012. The Giants are about where they should be as far as attendance numbers. The Rockies are a more know commodity around here and draw better that the last two. The Dodgers are sitting there less than some teams they should be above and have the star power that should bring people to the park but it just doesn't seem that way. The D'Backs are last and for good reason, just like the people of Phoenix, Cards fan are apathetic to their games at Busch Stadium.
American League Teams
- Los Angeles Angels, 43,540, 99.01%
- Cleveland Indians, 42,397, 96.41%
- Oakland Athletics, 42,012, 95.54%
- Kansas City Royals, 41,856, 95.18%
- Chicago White Sox, 41,494, 94.36%
- Seattle Mariners, 38,801, 88.23%
- Toronto Blue Jays, 38,185, 86.83%
The American League teams coming and playing inter-league games are kind of a novelty in a way and fans don't get to see these teams as often. The first five teams in the AL that played the Cardinals averaged more fans than only the Cubs. This might be because they see the National League teams once each and every year. The Angels managed to almost draw 100% attendance for a series in 2010. In 2012, the Cleveland Indians did a great job of bringing the fans for a team that wasn't in a pennant race last season. The "Money Ball" Oakland Athletics managed over 95% attendance, and the Royals in two series with the Cards in 2011 and 2012 managed over 95% attendance as well. The White Sox also managed to bring the folks in. Now the Mariners and Blue Jays weren't as high because they played the Cardinals during the week, so that skewed the numbers for them a little bit.
As you can see that sometimes teams with cache don't bring the fans out, see the Los Angeles Dodgers. Also teams that have been your long time rival will continue to draw the fans, 'Da Cubs. Some teams will surprise you like the Padres, who haven't been a great team in years past. And then some teams will be where you would imagine them to be like the Braves. All these attendance numbers are relative to time of week and if the Cardinals are in contention or even the results of the previous year. Look at the numbers from 2011 after the Cardinals lost in 2010. The average attendance went down to near 86%. Conversely after the Cardinals won the World Series in 2011, the average attendance went up to 91.58%. It is all relative in a way. As of today, so far in 2013 the Cardinals are around 91.5% average attendance and on line for the same numbers as 2012. I hope you found these stats entertaining and interesting.